Fighting Covid Spread with Science and Truth

November, 2020

Lincoln – A new research paper from the KU Institute for Policy and Social Research concludes that mask mandates are an effective way to fight Covid-19.  It analyzes the "natural experiment" underway in Kansas, previously discussed in an earlier post.

In Kansas, there was "a 50% reduction in the spread of COVID-19 in counties that had a mask mandate compared to those without."  This is a profoundly encouraging finding if we have the will to learn from it.  

Nebraska has a similar natural experiment underway, because mask mandates are in effect in Lancaster and Douglas counties but not elsewhere.  NU researchers should do a similar study and go one obvious step further: hypothesize and test a causal relationship, that the higher a county's percentage vote on November 3rd for Donald Trump (notably opposed to mask mandates), the higher the county Covid cases per capita.  

Aversion to masks and mask-mandates is observably rampant in rural Nebraska.  It must be considered a cause of the spread of Covid locally and elsewhere.  Going maskless is not just taking a risk with one's own life, it is an act of spreading the disease to others.  Rural Covid surges are actually taking over urban hospitals. From the Lincoln Journal Star:

Hospitalizations continue to surge in Lancaster County..., setting a new daily hospital census record for the third consecutive day. The vast majority of those hospitalized...are not Lancaster County residents....

The spread of disease has causes.  If this were the Bubonic Plague, we would be doing whatever we could to eliminate rats, fleas, and lice that spread it.  Likewise, we should deal honestly with spread of Covid by those who insist that the disease is a hoax, that masks don't work, or that individual freedom is at stake in the matter of mask mandates.  

Freedom is indeed at stake: the individual freedoms and the very lives of the victims of such beliefs and behaviors.  "The freedom to swing your fist ends where my nose begins." 

It is shameful that our elected leaders will not use their positions to fight Covid for all they are worth, by changing the behaviors of the maskless with mandates.  Mandates work.  It is time to put politics totally aside and save lives.  Enough with the years of false witness,* making victims of us all. 

The KU study demonstrates a use of the tools of science to discover truth.  May we read it – and heed it – north of the border. 

___________________________

* See the Ninth Commandment.





Dangerous Post-Election Strategies

November, 2020

Washington – As noted in earlier posts, the after-election strategies of both presidential contestants depend somewhat on which political party controls the House of Representatives on a one-vote-per-state basis, as provided in the Twelfth Amendment to the Constitution.  The losing candidate could try to move the presidential selection away from the Electoral College into the House, if his party controls it.  

Indeed, Donald Trump has lost the popular vote and is well behind in the Electoral College, but Republicans will control the House (on a one-vote-per-state basis), so a strategy is afoot to have Republican-controlled state legislatures certify alternative slates of electors in hopes that Joe Biden could be denied sufficient electoral votes to reach the 270 he needs to be declared the Electoral College winner.  

The rationale of the state legislatures would be that the popular elections in their respective states were fraudulent.  Although there seems to be no evidence of any significant fraud, a vigorous campaign is underway to make citizens believe there was.  

However, under law it is governors who certify electoral slates, so it becomes a question of which states did Biden win that have both Republican legislatures that would overturn a popular vote and a Republican governor who would certify a Republican slate of electors.  That appears to be only Arizona and Georgia.  But their combined 27 electoral votes, subtracted from Biden's current projection of 306, still leaves Biden with 279.  

What if Republican legislatures in Pennsylvania, Michigan, and Wisconsin, where Biden won the popular vote narrowly, certify slates to compete with the slates certified by their Democratic governors?  That would drop Biden below 270.  However, both houses of Congress must agree on rejection of any slates certified by governors, and the House, with a Democratic majority for such a vote, would not agree.

So it appears as if any strategy to deprive Biden of at least 270 electoral votes is not feasible, given the November 3rd election outcomes as they played out in each state.   

There is always the possibility that the courts might get involved and give a novel reading to the Constitution and to existing election laws, should any election questions come to them.  I believe this is unlikely.  It seems to me more plausible that the Roberts Court would reject such judicial contortions and instead use the occasion to try to restore Supreme Court credibility as an even-handed institution after making a misstep in Bush v. Gore in 2000.   The Court badly needs more credibility if it expects its other decisions to have public support.  

That leaves Trump with the use of the military to try to stay in power.  He has dismissed the Secretary of Defense, who showed an unwillingness to use the military for political purposes.  But Trump will also have to deal with the uniformed military leadership, which is doubtless preparing to resist misuse of the military in any effort to override the election outcome.  Officers are duty-bound to obey only lawful orders, and orders to overturn an election would not be among them.    

We can only hope it doesn't come to that, but to prepare for it if it does.  

Nebraska Covid Emergency

November, 2020

Lincoln – Nebraska's leading medical professionals are now in open public conflict with Governor Ricketts about how to deal with  Covid-19, which is out of control in Nebraska.  From the Omaha World-Herald:

Record numbers of COVID-19 cases and hospitalizations have prompted health care providers to call for Nebraska Gov. Pete Ricketts to adopt stricter health measures to stem the spread of the disease.

“Nebraska hospitals are suffering,” Dr. Erica Carlsson, an emergency medicine physician at Nebraska Medicine, said on Twitter. “Our ER’s are jam-packed and we are tired. We need real mandates, enforcement of those mandates and action by the government. Nebraskans will suffer and many will die if we keep up this pace of COVID spread.”

Similar messages were posted online by health care providers from the two other Omaha-based health systems....

Dr. James Lawler, a director at UNMC’s Global Center for Health Security, said health care providers’ calls for more action reflect “the frustration and desperation that my colleagues are experiencing.”

It's long overdue for the chasm to become public.  The governor and medical professionals have been in conflict since April, but not so publicly.  

The governor's response: 

A spokesman for Ricketts said the governor’s decisions regarding pandemic restrictions are based on science and data, not social media campaigns and tweets.

Ricketts said Thursday that he wanted to wait several more weeks to see the impact of directed health measures put into effect last month...

Several more weeks?  At the cost of how many lives?  Governor, back away as quickly as you can from your previous positions and start following the advice of medical professionals on the front lines.  It is they who are basing their advice on "science and data"; you are not.  Stop the claim that mandatory mask requirements are counterproductive; there is no such evidence. Stop threatening local governments with financial penalties if they take more aggressive actions than you propose.  Stop your state health department from overruling local officials who are closest to what their local communities need.  Stop the nonsense of looking at the trailing indicator of remaining hospital beds as your "North Star" to guide you.  The beds are soon full to overflowing, because you have been looking at trailing, not leading, indicators.  Nebraska business leaders know that, too, and have aligned themselves with the recommendations of the medical community.  

Governor Ricketts is not the only politician acting irresponsibly.  Former congressman and mayor of Omaha, Hal Daub, felt ill on election day, went to vote and on his way home obtained at test which proved his suspicions correct: it was Covid.  How many people did he infect at the polls?  

All of which raises the question of what President-elect Biden can do nationwide to fight the pandemic now, because he does not take office until January 20th and the incumbent president has disengaged himself from consideration of immediate countermeasures against the pandemic.  

Recommendation:  when Biden appoints his Covid task force this week, he should ask them to come up with suggestions that would have bipartisan support and even get the current administration's agreement for immediate action where possible.  

For example, one suggestion would be to have the incumbent president use the Defense Production Act to authorize federal agencies like FEMA, DoD, and DHS to coordinate production and distribution of medical supplies, as well as emerging Covid treatments, among the states.  The president has already said he would use federal agencies to distribute vaccines, so this overdue action should not be seen as any fundamental violation of principles of federalism.

Another suggestion would be to obtain early agreement on a Covid legislative package by involving key Republican governors in negotiations to break the current congressional impasse.  Governors Charlie Baker, Phil Scott, and Larry Hogan know that getting help to states on a bipartisan basis is crucial to keeping local governments functioning.  That assistance would be not only for frontline health workers but also to keep firemen and policemen on the job, which the current administration should surely be ready to support.  

A key to combating Covid everywhere is not to wait until January 20th, but to get a running start on bipartisan actions by involving responsible Republican governors immediately.  

___________________________

P.S.  (Three days later)  It's good to see the message that we can't wait from UNMC's Dr. Lawler, in the national press.  Read it here. 

Incredible Victory for Democracy

November, 2020

Washington, Lincoln, Berlin – The 2020 U.S. election, now winding up, will go down in history as one of democracy's greatest triumphs.  Pundits claiming it was somehow a calamity are wrong.

Look at the popular vote: the spread between Joe Biden and Donald Trump is four million and counting.  Importantly, that's not just Democratic votes; it includes votes from Republicans who split their tickets.  Republican candidates ran ahead of Trump in many races.  The incumbent, democratic norm-breaking president is being ousted on a bipartisan basis.  From Maine through Nebraska to California, Trump underperformed.  This gives nascent hope to Never Trump Republicans and those who want to return the party more to its founding principles.   

I'm also looking at what this election might do to shake up the Democratic Party, which badly needs to reconsider its election strategies.  The party may now be forced into an overdue understanding of various constituencies whose voices it has badly neglected — Hispanics and rural Americans are two obvious examples.  The Democratic Party must also clean its house of advisers who are so out of touch with America that they failed, while winning the presidency, to take the Senate and almost lost the House (not to mention their 2016 election fiasco and the Senate losses in 2018).  

But back to the historic nature of this election.  It's a huge victory for democracy, even comparable to the fall of the Berlin Wall, to D-Day, and to the Battle of Midway.*  Let there be no mistake about the 2020 election: democracy in the U.S. faced a hugely difficult challenge, not unlike great struggles of the last century. 

How can 2020 compare to those events?  Consider these very real threats:

First, a large segment of the U.S. dangerously developed a taste for un-presidential behavior in its leader, fed by news media the likes of which have not been seen since the heyday of Dr. Joseph Goebbels, the propagandist of Germany's Third Reich.  The more Trump broke norms, even of truth and decency, the more his base adherents cheered. Second, opposition party Democrats played into media hands by failing to develop their own disciplined messaging, allowing Democrats to be successfully, however wrongly, characterized as opponents of law and order, as socialists, and as totalitarians themselves who would end free speech.  Third, voter suppression techniques were widely applied by Republican Party operatives as never before, in an attempt to intimidate, discourage, and disqualify Democratic voters, all during an ongoing pandemic. 

I give much credit for overcoming these obstacles to citizens who stood for hours in long, long lines to vote, despite all. They risked their lives for democratic values.  I also give much credit to ticket-splitting Republicans (there were many), who mustered a final measure of decency and respect for our form of government to make this a bipartisan and historic victory for democracy itself.  

What did this victory prevent?  Another four years of increasingly autocratic rule, in my view, would have shredded our hard-earned international alliances, especially NATO; destroyed the best of our Civil Service; made the judicial branch subservient to the executive branch; squandered another four years in the race for climate change solutions; and undermined the integrity of future elections.  

No Kaiser, Emperor, Czar, or Comrade-Chairman ever posed a greater threat to our democracy than did the situation into which our country blundered with the election of 2016.  The disastrous fallout from that election has proved to be second only to the danger once presented by Der Führer, in my assessment.   

Let us build on this incredible 2020 election to end a shameful chapter of American history.  There is much to build on.  However, it does not serve us well to demonize those who did not contribute to the victory.  I understand Trump voters; many are not independent actors so much as media-addicted collections of vulnerable humans overwhelmed by messages of fear and division, and they reacted accordingly.  It's time to reach out to them with a more hopeful and understanding approach, which action should also be a tonic for those on the winning side as well.  

Look at the popular vote; look at the bipartisan nature of the Trump repudiation; look at the obvious yearning among voters for a return to decency and democratic values.  This was a truly great election. 

_______________________________

* Midway was a narrow escape from an Asian, fascist-aligned, totalitarian power.  The 1942 battle, like the 2020 election, could easily have gone the other way.  We lost the carrier USS Yorktown, but the Japanese lost four carriers.  The victory only stopped the enemy's advance; it did not end the war, which would go on for three more years.  But it was an incredible victory nonetheless, and gave democracy hope.  

*  D-Day was another difficult victory for democratic governments. General Eisenhower was so uncertain of the outcome that he had a speech ready to admit failure.  But the 1944 amphibious landing at Normandy was ultimately a success and led to an end of the war a year later, over European fascism.  

* The fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989 represented a rollback of communist totalitarianism and a resounding victory for democratic governments.  It was brought about by resolute democracies, to be sure, but also by internal weaknesses in authoritarianism, which failed to take into account democratic impulses in oppressed populations.  




Test of Character

November, 2020

Lincoln –  Nebraskans, confronting an alarming increase in Covid-19 infections, are facing a test of character.  Will we fight the pandemic or, like some other states in our region, give up and let the disease run its course, at whatever horrible cost?  

There are discouraging reports from Iowa, the Dakotas, and other states where governors say there is nothing they can do.  Nebraska Governor Ricketts has also been in that camp from the outset; his North Star guide has been to hospitalize those who becomes sick, not to use his powers to limit the number of cases.  Instead, he urges "individual responsibility."     

Now the hospitals are about to be overwhelmed.  The governor responds by saying that Nebraska has low unemployment.  But Nebraska always has low unemployment.  

There is a glimmer of hope in Nebraska, as the governor's appointed state health director has finally acknowledged the obvious, as reported by the Lincoln JournalStar:  
 
Dr. Gary Anthone, the state's chief medical officer, said "it is obvious that we are headed in the wrong direction" as COVID-19 cases continue to grow and spread across the state while hospital beds begin to fill.

"We cannot surge our way out of this pandemic by increasing hospital beds or staffing," he said. "We need to stop the number of cases rising daily. We need to decrease the number of people who are hospitalized."


Perhaps this statement is a harbinger of a change in state policy.  Governor Ricketts needs to get in step with local elected officials who want to fight the pandemic; he should not continue to oppose their efforts.*  Fighting the pandemic with "individual responsibility" makes no more sense than relying on people's good judgment about how fast to drive, or whether to buy auto insurance, or whether to poison groundwater resources with atrazine.  Collective action is sometimes necessary to protect the health and well-being of the greater population.  This is one of those times. 

This is a test of character.  Facing down the disease will require facing down those who would give up.

____________________________
* The governor and attorney general have opposed local mask mandates, despite their efficacy and despite the support of many businesses that also welcome them because they provide greater protection for those who want to patronize the businesses, not to mention controlling infections more generally. 

Nebraskans: Raise Our Ranking to Save Lives

October, 2020

Lincoln –  Nebraska is being hit hard by Covid-19.  Why?  The following graphic offers a likely explanation.  The coefficient of determination between the variables (R-squared) is .73.  It suggests Nebraska's high Covid-19 ranking is attributable in considerable part to its low ranking in masking-up. 





The graphic comports to anecdotal evidence.  South Dakota, which famously hosted two largely maskless super-spreader events last summer at Mount Rushmore and Sturgis, is very bad off.  South Dakota Governor Noem is, at best, ambivalent about masks. Nebraska politicians, led by Governor Ricketts and Attorney General Peterson, advocate masks but send a mixed message by threatening legal action against local governments that require them.  

Nebraskans, when it comes to football, are ranking-obsessed.  Our state university's football team is going nowhere this year in national rankings, but if Nebraskans would come together to raise our ranking in mask-wearing, it could be a source of state pride as well as save lives.  

A look at the graphic suggests that even an increase of ten percent in masking-up would move Nebraska into the top ranks of the nation, certainly into the top ten.  

Who might take the lead to put Nebraska into national leadership?  Local elected officials; the University of Nebraska Medical Center; newspaper editors; and the business community, led by the Lincoln and Omaha chambers of commerce.  

The Lincoln Chamber already has a "Mask-Up Lincoln" effort underway, which could be expanded statewide.  The business group quotes the NU Medical Center leader, Dr. Jeffrey Gold, calling for us to work together "shoulder to shoulder," and acknowledges the business community's own "special responsibility" to speak up:  

“We’re at a critical moment in time. We’re going to get through this and emerge stronger as a society, state and country. We’re going to have to do it together, shoulder to shoulder.”

The Lincoln Chamber recognizes our prominent status in the community as a trusted, nonpartisan, collaborative organization places a special responsibility upon us to speak out. We urge all citizens of Lincoln to remember that we will all play a vital role in safely navigating this pandemic.

Let's put self-respect, respect for others, and pride of ranking* back into our behavior and emerge from this pandemic with a sense that we Nebraskans have met what many around the country, and around the world, say is ultimately a test of character.  Not to mention more of us taking personal responsibility to help our communities.  

__________________________

* Of course it's possible that other states will pick up their efforts and leave Nebraska even further behind.  An analysis of 26 Republican governors shows that 21 of them have moved on masking-up beyond the Trump administration's recommendations and only 5, including Nebraska's, are echoing Trump.  However, many of the 21 made their moves months ago, so it is not futile for Nebraska now to catch up through a united, citizen-led effort and pass them.  And look at the slope of the line: a 10% increase in masking-up might reduce cases 20%.  Think of our front-line hospital workers; think of our struggling economy.  Let's not give up.  



Student Loans: "What is Really Going On"

October, 2020

Washington – Both the legislative and judicial branches of the federal government have recently taken note of on-going irregularities at the U.S. Department of Education.  One wonders what took so long, but better late (in these cases, very late) than never.

On October 19, in a class action case against Secretary Betsy DeVos, a federal district judge threw out a settlement between the parties that was supposed to have resolved hundreds of thousands of long-standing student loan borrowers' claims for relief, due the borrowers because for-profit colleges had defrauded them.  The judge wrote of a typical claim:

[T]he borrower’s path forward rings disturbingly Kafkaesque*....  Questions of legality plague the Secretary’s new perfunctory denial notice.... We need an updated record and updated discovery....  We need to know what is really going on. 

Then, on October 22, regarding manipulation of accreditation by the DeVos Department, the chairman of the House Labor and Education committee issued subpoenas to get at the truth of the matter, writing this to the Secretary: 

Due to the Department’s obstruction, the Committee’s only available avenue to obtain an accurate understanding of the Department’s role in the Dream Center collapse is to pursue depositions of the knowledgeable Department officials under subpoena. Accordingly, the Committee has served such subpoenas on the relevant Department staff.

Earlier in the year, the House Appropriations Committee put a stop to a major contract about to be awarded to a troubled student loan servicer under dubious circumstances.  

The common thread connecting these three debacles involving billions of taxpayer dollars is agency corruption at the highest levels.  It did not start with Betsy DeVos, by the way, but she has greatly exacerbated it.  I was at the department in 2001 when corruption got its initial foothold, and I witnessed it in action.  Many of the same people are still involved, as their fingerprints can be seen on each of the above scandals.  

If the other branches want "to know what is really going on"— and I believe they do — there are excellent sources beyond what they will find in discovery and through subpoenas.  One is Republic Report, where in its many iterations the peerless David Halperin explains the interconnections between predatory colleges and department personnel.  Another is this blog (Three Capitals), which has explained in several posts over the past two years the corruption involved in the department's dealings with the student loan industry.  Still another is Dan E. Moldea's new book, Money, Politics, and Corruption in U.S. Higher Education, which offers much relevant material from discovery and subpoenas in other investigations. 

For details on what a federal judge found to be Kafkaesque, the webpage of the Project on Predatory Student Lending provides a veritable library of such cases.  Inspector General reports, routinely ignored within the department, are another source. 

Let's get on with determining "what is really going on."  Upcoming depositions and testimonies under oath must require answers to questions about how and why department personnel, political appointees and civil servants alike, systematically set about to deprive borrowers their rights under law, violating in the process statutes prohibiting conflict of interest, obstruction of justice (including state law enforcement), perjury, and contempt of both the courts and Congress.  

______________________________  

*  Franz Kafka has a Berlin connection; for a time in the 1920s he lived in Berlin-Steglitz, at Grunewaldstrasse 13.  I passed the site often when I lived in Steglitz many years ago, not ever thinking a U.S. federal judge would someday compare Kafka's bizarre world to that of student loan victims.    

Catholic Voters and Abortion Politics

October, 2020

Lincoln – Not being raised Catholic, and not having much interest in a religion based on dogma that its leader is infallible, I nevertheless respect many Catholic institutions and individuals. That includes the Jesuits, for example, for their dedication to teaching and scholarship, and the social and political outreach work of a few recent popes.   

But when internal Catholic arguments spill over and threaten American political institutions, and twist our body politic into contortions for a single legal decision that is surely counterproductive to its own purported goal, my even limited admiration ends.  

That decision, of course, is to overrule Roe v. Wade.  

Thomas M. Kelly, professor of systematic theology at Creighton University in Omaha, a Jesuit institution, explains the internal contradictions within the anti-abortion debate:

Catholic countries of Latin America and Muslim countries of North Africa and the Middle East, which outlaw abortion, have the highest abortion rates in the world....  What has been shown to reduce abortions is universal access to health care, contraception (which over 95% of Catholics use) and social safety nets for poor and single women, especially those without family networks.

Meanwhile, Donald J. Trump has appointed three Supreme Court justices who will, he says, repeal Roe.  The three have also demonstrated hostility toward universal health care programs.  In celebration of his latest appointment, the president brought many people to the White House during a pandemic, which became a coronavirus super-spreader event.  Among those was the president of the University of Notre Dame, the Rev. John I. Jenkins, a native Nebraskan, who at the behest of the White House went unmasked and promptly caught the virus.  

Another Catholic university president, Patricia McGuire* of Trinity University Washington, took him to task:

Truth be told, the academic attendees parked more than their masks at the door. Bad example comes in many forms, including complicit silence in the face of official wrongs. This is an administration that has deliberately and with malice waged a deadly war against medical and public-health evidence about the pandemic, dishonoring doctors and epidemiologists by mocking their advice and excluding them from decision-making roles, even going so far as attempting to silence them. The unmasked presence of the academic leaders in the Rose Garden gave tacit consent to the silencing of those who have tried to save lives by providing correct information.

The Covid-19 pandemic has imposed harsh and unforgiving sacrifices on people not as famous or powerful as those gathered in the Rose Garden. As I looked at the photos of that elite group, I could not help but think of the millions of school children unable to sit in their classrooms because of the pandemic. I thought of the thousands of high-school and college seniors denied the joys of real graduations. I thought of the deep and pervasive grief coursing through the families and communities of the 210,000 dead, so many dying alone without the comforting touch of loved ones, with survivors bearing the uniquely awful pain of not even being able to gather for funerals. I thought of the courage of so many front-line health-care heroes, the nurses and doctors sometimes forced to wear makeshift PPE because of a lack of adequate supplies. I thought of the grand weddings made small, the laid-off waiters of shuttered restaurants, the desperation of parents who are essential workers risking their health in low-wage jobs to keep food on the table, racing home at odd hours to help their kids keep learning at kitchen tables where computers and internet access are spotty or rare.

So where does this leave the so-called pro-life voters?  It seems to me they have become pawns for all kinds of bad causes, none of which is actually pro-life.  It is the worst of all worlds.  Not to mention that the repeal of Roe would only multiply these conflicts, into the legislatures of the fifty states.  

May the coming election provide a way forward.  

_____________________

* Patricia McGuire herself is not unfamiliar with visits to the White House.  I remember her well from meetings many years ago in the EOB, when she advocated for disadvantaged students and I came over to the offices from the Department of Education.  When she learned that my hometown was Lincoln, Nebraska, she asked about her good friend Larry Arth.  Larry Arth was a graduate of Pius X high school, chairman of Ameritas Life Insurance Co., and active in charity work.  He and I had been classmates at UNL, where we were both in Navy ROTC and took summer training cruises together.  Sadly, he passed away in 2008.  

P.S. See also the positions of Catholic theologians writing in the Omaha World-Herald. 

Twentieth Century Philosophers

 October, 2020

Washington – For those of us who need to brush up from time to time on our Wittgenstein, Gödel, and Heidegger, there is a fine book review by Adam Kirsch in The New Yorker about the Vienna Circle and what it propounded.  

The review is a model of writing with clarity, making sense of difficult concepts.

Readers will learn who murdered Professor Schlick – when, why, and how.  Through this tale we are given a new appreciation of the importance of the 1930s and the era's relevance for our own times.  

Most of us live in Wittgenstein's world, not Heidegger's, but it is worth reflecting on what it was that attracted Heidegger to the Nazis and whether we might be headed in the same direction.  

It's good to know that all of the Vienna Circle survived the Nazis.  May logical empiricism survive our current era.  

 

 



"The Freedom to Swing your Fist..."

October, 2020

Lincoln and Berlin – In Nebraska and its neighboring states of Iowa, South Dakota, Wyoming, and Missouri, Covid-19 cases are on an alarming upswing.  

So is a new description of "freedom," which heretofore has been well-defined by the memorable aphorism, "The freedom to swing your fist ends where my nose begins."  To many in these states, that definition of freedom no longer applies.

The two developments are linked, as significant numbers of residents refuse to follow public health measures like social distancing and mask-wearing to curb the spread of the disease.  They say that to follow them is a violation of their freedom.  Unfortunately, they are given support and encouragement by top elected officials, including the governors of these states, who decline to mandate and enforce public health measures that would curtail Covid-19, and who even threaten local officials who favor such measures.

Siding with those who metaphorically swing their fists into others' noses, the governors have imperiled many other freedoms that we once enjoyed.  These include the freedom to travel safely, to associate in proximity with friends and family, to carry on businesses and business activities, to vote safely at polling places, to send our children safely to schools.  I feel the loss of these freedoms acutely; so surely do most of us. 

Is there any serious political theory behind defining the "freedom" of a few in such a way that so directly takes away the freedoms of the many?  Such ideas were once dismissed as crackpot, and deservedly so. 

But with so many governors embracing the notion that it is their governments' role to protect swinging one's fist with abandon in the name of freedom, leaving sickness and death as a consequence, it is time to take a new look at what reasoning is behind it.  We deserve and should be demanding answers.

The governors' notion is closely aligned with an urge to give up and not fight the coronavirus, to see it as inevitable, to let it run its course.  Nebraska Governor Ricketts from the outset has suggested the virus cannot be stopped; his actions have never been premised on limiting the number of cases, but on sending the sick to hospitals.  This often aligns with the Trumpist view of the virus, which waxes and wanes irresolutely, depending on entertainment value and the need to distract from scandal. 

There are shades of Social Darwinism in such thinking: survival of the fittest.  Those with good genes will survive.  This is not a new idea.  We once went to war against it.

Which not coincidentally brings us to Berlin, a city bracing for another wave of the virus but with a different approach.  Rather than twisting the meaning of freedom to rationalize giving up, as parts of America are on the verge of doing, German health minister Jens Spahn describes the upcoming struggle simply as a "test of character."  German public health measures are in place.  Along with good political leadership and reliance on leading-edge science, Germany beat back the first wave of the virus and saved thousands of lives, compared to the poorly led American effort.  For the second wave, it will be up to the strength and will of the people to overcome the virus.  

Outcomes everywhere are much in doubt.  I'm pulling for those, wherever they are, who summon strength of character to fight the virus, rather than giving up in the name of a bizarre notion of freedom that is destroying the real freedoms we all want once again to enjoy. 

__________________________

Post Script (five days later):  Glad to see the same points now being made more widely by Michael Tomasky in the New York Times, 17 October 2020.  He juxtaposes Austrian economists against John Stuart Mill.