Lincoln – As good as Ross Benes's new book Rural Rebellion is — and believe me, it is good — there are a few references to the legendary Governor and Senator Jim Exon that could use additional context so no one comes away with misconceptions. Overall, the book gets Jim Exon right; the following are notations for those who want as complete a record as possible, and for me to engage in a little speculation about what Jim Exon might think if he were alive today.*
"Rural Rebellion" and Big Jim Exon
Lincoln – As good as Ross Benes's new book Rural Rebellion is — and believe me, it is good — there are a few references to the legendary Governor and Senator Jim Exon that could use additional context so no one comes away with misconceptions. Overall, the book gets Jim Exon right; the following are notations for those who want as complete a record as possible, and for me to engage in a little speculation about what Jim Exon might think if he were alive today.*
"Rural Rebellion" Review
February, 2021
Lincoln and Washington – Whoa. Ross Benes of Brainard, Nebraska, of the proud Czech immigrant families who settled in Nebraska's Bohemian Alps, son of parents who run Ron's Plumbing and Heating, hardly into his thirties, has written a book on Nebraska politics so compelling and full of wisdom it has lessons for the entire nation.
Although some will read Rural Rebellion as a bildungsroman of a young conservative activist transitioning into a mature and more forbearing adult, that is only part of it. Others will read the book as the jarring experience of a person who must interpret between two different cultures, Brainard and New York City, where Benes now lives. But that's not the essence of it either, as thousands of us with deep roots in both the rural heartland and in big coastal cities do it all the time.
Rather, the greatest value of the book rests in its raw exposure of the myopia of both regions and both political parties. Benes is brutal in his truth-telling, born of his own pain and the conclusions he draws from his experiences.
He organizes his work for maximum effect, with a chapter first on the Catholic church and the politics of abortion, followed by chapters on immigration, health care, the state unicameral legislature, the state university, the ineptitude of the Democratic party, and his concluding recommendations.
It is his first chapter that is most powerful, about his disaffection with the church. It casts a long shadow over the subsequent chapters, for good reason: the crass manipulation of the abortion issue by Republicans has poisoned much in all political life. Benes barely touches on other religious influences on politics, such as the once dominant, progressive Social Gospel movement of W. J. Bryan, founder of the modern Democratic Party, and its vision for improving the lives of the common classes through responsive government. That tradition has disappeared, almost as if it never happened, replaced by single-issue politics.
Throughout the book, Benes illustrates his points with well-chosen anecdotes. What seem like elections of only local interest, such as the contest for Omaha mayor between Jean Stothert and Heath Mello, have state and national implications. Democrat Mello, an excellent candidate, could have won, were it not for incredible bungling by the Democratic party's campaign strategy. Yet no one has learned much from it in the years since.
Benes shows no mercy toward Governor Pete Ricketts and his attempt to undo the supreme achievement of Nebraska government, the non-partisan unicameral legislature of George Norris. He reveals the current governor to be all about money, power, and retribution. He extolls former Democratic governors like Jim Exon, Bob Kerrey, and Ben Nelson for their ability to reach across party lines, although his Exon examples unfortunately are somewhat out of focus and will need further analysis so as to sharpen them. But that is for another time.
If Rural Rebellion has a weak chapter, it is the one on the University of Nebraska. Benes focuses too much on the constant quarreling about the actions of a few faculty and graduate students on the left. The governance, administration, and a large slice of the faculty of the institution are profoundly of the right, and it shows throughout the state's politics. Why are towns like Brainard struggling to survive and why is rural Nebraska losing population? Would it have anything to do with food and agriculture policy, which has been set by conservative interests for decades? The shorthand admonition to generations of farmers has been to get-big-or-get-out. The university creates monuments to those who abetted rural depopulation, but the political uproar of recent years at the institution is all about a campus sidewalk argument. Dwelling on it only serves to miss the larger role of the university.
Rural Rebellion rebounds as Benes looks critically at national political leadership, especially from U.S. Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer. Schumer in 2016 insisted that for every working-class voter Democrats lost in places like Brainard, they would pick up two in the suburbs. Schumer of all people should know that only control of the House, not the Senate or the presidency, rests with the popular vote. That miscalculation cost Democrats dearly in 2016, 2018, and made 2020 a nail-biter in all three centers of power. Neglect of the rural heartland by national Democrats has led to near disaster for our very democracy. Benes's book went to press before the January 6th insurrection, but it is in the spirit of his analysis to ask why the fist-saluting, insurrectionist supporter Senator Josh Hawley was elected in Missouri over Senator Claire McCaskill in 2018, and why Senators Heidi Heitkamp and Joe Donnelly from rural states also lost that year. Was it because Chuck Schumer and others in the Democratic leadership wrote off rural America by deciding, as they did, not to offer a Democratic vision for the 2018 Farm Bill? It certainly didn't help.
The book has a satisfying conclusion. Benes offers good remedies for our broken politics, like open primaries and rank-order voting. He also shares recent personal conversations from Brainard. Spoiler alert: be ready for a happy ending.
Ross Benes will inevitably be compared to Thomas Frank, who writes cogently on similar themes. Benes has a better feel for the people he is writing about, because he is one of them. Or perhaps I should say one of us, as my Nebraska home is just a county away down the Oak Creek Valley from Brainard. If our country is to emerge more united than it has been in recent years, it will be on strength of books like Rural Rebellion.
Bad Start for Biden at DOJ
February, 2021
Washington – The Biden administration is off to a rocky start at the Department of Justice if last week's eyebrow-raising move by acting assistant attorney general Brian Boynton is any indication of things to come.
The newly-appointed official acted to protect former Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos from being held accountable for denying defrauded student-loan borrowers their rights under law, joining DeVos's personal counsel in a federal court filing to prevent DeVos from having to give a deposition in a case brought by the victims of multiple cases of fraud, as perpetrated by for-profit colleges.
Even if he felt there was somehow an institutional DOJ responsibility to object to cabinet secretaries being deposed (and that is a stretch, because the deposition was not sought until after DeVos resigned, and a federal district judge had cleared it), the vehemence in the filing is startling. It is directed at the defrauded borrowers' counsel, the Project on Predatory Student Lending at the Harvard Law School, which has long been respected for being one of the few places to which victims can turn to protect their rights under law. PPSL has a remarkable record of success in federal court on behalf of those whose lives are being ruined by predatory lending.
There is little doubt that DeVos herself was responsible for blocking justice for tens of thousands of defrauded borrowers, just as she was responsible for blocking collection of millions of dollars of false claims owed back to taxpayers from a large student-loan lender. Days after she resigned last month, the Department of Education finally, and rightly, collected from the lender.
I hope I am wrong about this, but the action by Boynton, who will head DOJ's Civil Division, appears to be a warning shot across the bow from the for-profit college industry, which overlaps with the student loan lender/servicer industry, announcing that the revolving door between government and industry still turns, despite the November elections. Government offices captured by industry over the past two decades will not easily be given up. Boynton has a substantial record of working for these industries, both inside and outside government.
Would a recusal in his case be appropriate? Surely it would be, on the merits or on appearances, or both. But there is a long history of non-recusals and recusal violations when it comes to for-profit colleges and the lender/servicer industry.
My own experience with DOJ over many years has had its ups and downs, often intertwined with recusal issues. DOJ took two years to decide against joining my litigation against nine student-loan lenders in 2007 for false claims, rather than the two months prescribed. I believe anyone who ever looked at the evidence would be surprised if not astonished that DOJ did not take over the suit itself at some point, so as seek sanctions against the perpetrators. Failures of recusal were central to those cases, as the industry had its former officials in key Department of Education positions during the years of false claims.*
However, DOJ was helpful twice in filing memoranda with federal courts to dispute the perpetrators' defense, which led to several settlements, although there were no convictions for wrongdoing. Likewise, the Solicitor General's office at DOJ was helpful in advising the Supreme Court, which asked its opinion, not to accept a lender's writ of certiorari to overturn a loss of sovereign immunity, incurred in my litigation, from borrowers' and states' lawsuits.
But coming on the heels of that decision in 2017, Betsy DeVos moved to create another way to block borrowers from seeking redress, a "preemption" doctrine claiming that the federal Higher Education Act preempts state consumer protection laws. DOJ, in support of DeVos, filed briefs to aid the perpetrator's attempt to derail a state attorney general's lawsuit to protect aggrieved student-loan borrowers.
This came at the time when I was still in court against the same party, trying to reach settlement on long-standing issues, with DOJ personnel present at lawyer-client discussions, because I was acting on behalf of the United States even though DOJ had not taken over the case. DOJ never informed me that they were simultaneously assisting the opposing party on a related case, which seemed to me an ethical violation on top of all the damage it was doing to borrower victims' interests.
Fortunately, the DOJ maneuvering against a state attorney general lost decisively at the state court level and several federal courts have since ruled against the DeVos preemption doctrine as well. But the damage was done. Only in the past few days has Massachusetts settled with the deficient servicer, PHEAA, to provide redress to up to 250,000 of its residents. Other states cannot be far behind.
Industry capture of federal offices through revolving door appointments and iron-triangle relationships is a longstanding problem. At the Department of Education it is particularly acute. Both the borrower defense issue now contested in the deposition controversy, and the preemption issue now being unravelled by the courts, are prime examples of policies developed and implemented by those whose first loyalty is to industry. Recusals are one way of dealing with the problem, but only if they are enforced.
A good question of Attorney General designate Merrick Garland at his confirmation hearing on February 22nd would be to ask if he is prepared to enforce recusals throughout the government, including at DOJ itself.
________________________
* Investigative journalist Dan E. Moldea, in Money, Politics, and Corruption in U.S. Higher Education (2020), illustrated two obvious instances of conflicts of interest and recusal violations. One involved an assistant secretary who passed along inside information to her former employer about upcoming audits; another showed how a top industry association official who became deputy secretary abetted the filing of false claims against taxpayers. No action was ever taken against either. It is not hard to draw a straight line from those individuals to the multiple student-loan imbroglios of today, continuing on into the future, unless the Biden administration is ready to scrub out this disgraceful legacy.
Beautiful Legal Language
February, 2021
Washington – Sometimes a sentence appears in an otherwise dry government ruling that is too good, even too humorous, not to single out and savor. I don't know the actual author, but surely this line (highlighted below in full context), from a decision requiring a student loan lender to repay $22.3 million of false claims made against taxpayers, was written with a knowing smile:
"The analysis essential to Navient’s case is the language of the controlling statute and duly promulgated regulations. Policy guidance in the form of a DCL may be helpful in implementing new rules, but such guidance cannot conflict with laws established by Congress or regulations enacted through the rulemaking process....
"The sentence at issue [in the DCL] appears on page 13. Navient asserts that this sentence constitutes the Department’s new and binding interpretation of the law allowing the 9.5 percent floor to be billed on obligations funded partially with tax-exempt and partially with taxable funds. I am unpersuaded that the Department had any intention of hiding a new legal interpretation in a clause in the middle of an otherwise innocuous sentence on the thirteenth page of DCL 93-L161. I agree with FSA’s position and the administrative judge’s holding that DCL 93-L-161 did not and could not establish a binding legal position of the Department that conflicts with the existing statute and regulations. (emphasis added)
Ya think?
Yet on such bizarre findings of hidden meanings were taxpayers defrauded in the hundreds of millions of dollars fourteen years ago by several lenders. And it could have been in the billions.
Lenders like SLFC, KHESLC, and PHEAA employed even more preposterous interpretations of DCLs to make false claims. They once asserted, trying to keep straight faces, that a 1996 DCL's Q and A section, item 30, essentially overturned a 1993 act of Congress.
If only someone in authority back in 2007 had said, with a felicitous turn of phrase, that they were "unpersuaded that the Department would hide language in item 30 of a Q and A subsection of a sub-regulatory DCL in order to overrule Congress." But back then the Department was controlled by the lenders, so no one did.
I recall being present at a deposition in which a lawyer representing lenders knew he'd be asked about such an interpretation. At the outset, the lawyer said he was sick and under heavy medication, so his understanding of the questions to be put to him, let alone his answers, might not be totally reliable. Another lawyer spoke during his deposition with a twinkle in his eye throughout: of course he believed what he was saying; he was even paid $5,000 for his opinion.*
Perhaps someone in the Biden Administration will take note. It may be too late to undo what lenders got by with in the past, but it is not too late to investigate how it happened and to clean house of those aiding and abetting false claims in federal student loan programs. There are many collaborators still around in the interest groups, in the law offices, in loan servicing companies, and in the Department.
While it is good to recover $22.3 million, it will be even better if integrity and the rule of law are finally restored to the Department itself.
_______________________________
* Interrogating lawyers, condescension dripping, asked why only $5000? Any K Street firm would have charged at least $20,000 for an opinion that would bag millions for a client.
Student Loan Surprise
February, 2021
Washington – For "man bites dog" stories, it's hard to top this one, coming from the student loan world: Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos abruptly resigned whereupon her deputy secretary moved quickly, once she was gone, to recover an estimated $22.3 million from a lender that had filed false claims against federal taxpayers more than a decade ago, but never repaid despite an OIG audit.
The action to recover was unexpected, to say the least, during the remaining days of the Trump Administration, which was expected to find a way to excuse the lender, as it had other such lenders over the years. The action was reported quickly by Politico, the Washington Post, and the New York Times.
The Washington Post gave readers context: "The Education Department’s decision stems from a scandal that signaled the beginning of the end of a system that enriched financial firms at the expense of taxpayers."But here is what the decision said with regard to that letter: "[A] Dear Colleague letter is a mechanism to provide guidance on existing laws and regulations, not to establish new rules. DCL FP-07-01 does not have the force or authority of a statute or regulation, it has no power to obviate the enforcement of such laws, and it does not establish a binding and enforceable contract between the Department and Navient to waive the liability established in the OIG Audit."
Norman Krivosha Remembered
January, 2021
Lincoln – Norman Krivosha, former chief justice of the Nebraska Supreme Court, made remarkable contributions to Lincoln and to Nebraska. He passed away last week in Florida.
A newspaper article noting his passing contained one sentence that should not have made it into print: "In both 1984 and 1986, he had the lowest rating of the Supreme Court members in an evaluation conducted by the Nebraska Bar Association."
This sentence badly needs more context than it was given. James Hewitt provides it in a 2005 article on the relationship between the court and the bar:
Bar leadership would undoubtedly have rated Chief Justice Krivosha significantly higher than did the bar as a whole. He was helpful, cooperative, and enthusiastic in dealing with the bar. It is difficult to understand why he earned such low ratings, unless lawyers as a group resented his public battles with Mike Royko* over the court's striking of the death penalty in State v. Hunt. Perhaps his death penalty dissents did him a disservice, or maybe it was his efforts to move tort law into the twentieth century. In any case, he was not a favorite of the rank and file, and the bar leaders must bear some of the blame for failing to make the membership more aware of his cooperation.
Norman Krivosha could rub people the wrong way, to be sure. Even after Hewitt defended him for the historical record, Krivosha did not return the favor. He couldn't resist saying that Governor Norbert Tiemann lost re-election because of "Whiz Kids who thought Nebraskans were too dumb."** Jim Hewitt was one of the Tiemann Whiz Kids.
I got on Krivosha's wrong side at least once. In the mid-70s, when he was advising Governor Jim Exon as unpaid counsel, I wrote something that came to his attention in which I used the term ultra vires. Norm didn't think people in the state budget division should use language like that. It was a term reserved for people who knew what they were talking about, he said.
Such could be said for the unfortunate sentence in the article on his passing. Norman Krivosha was a great chief justice and an even finer human being.
___________________________
* As to the Royko controversy: I quit reading the nationally published Chicago columnist after his 1985 attack on Krivosha and the Nebraska Supreme Court. They had the difficult task of determining what the state legislature had in mind when it reserved the death penalty for "especially heinous" acts, as opposed to ordinary heinous ones, whatever those may be. Royko admitted to not reading the decision.
** (2013) Palleson and Van Pelt, Big Jim Exon, p. 85.
Naming Lincoln's New High Schools
Lincoln – Two new high schools in Lincoln are about to be named. The school board historically has named high schools with directional designations, but one of the new schools, southeast of the city, cannot be named Lincoln Southeast because the name is already taken.
Virginia Smith and Donald Trump
January, 2021
Lincoln – Two Nebraskans with long experience in Washington have reacted in print to the January 6th insurrection at the U.S. Capitol. They are former Washington-based reporters for the Omaha World-Herald, Randy Moody and Mary Kay Quinlan.
Mary Kay Quinlan went on to be leader of the National Press Club and associate dean of the University of Nebraska–Lincoln school of journalism.
She looked back at former Nebraska lawmakers and how they might have reacted to Donald Trump taking over the Republican party and inciting the insurrectionists. She doubted that some of them, especially the third district's Virginia Smith, "would even recognize a party whose voters have fallen in thrall to an unprincipled, uncouth, failed businessman turned 'reality' TV star whose years of lies resulted in last week’s storming of the Capitol."
She goes on to write, "Regrettably, the voters of Nebraska’s 3rd Congressional District, who overwhelmingly reelected Mrs. Smith for nearly two decades, are the same voters who overwhelmingly sought to return to office the man whose supporters charitably could be considered would-be performance artists."Much there to unpack. I spent several years in Washington at many of the same venues as Mary Kay Quinlan, amid the same Nebraska representatives. I agree with her about today's Nebraska voters, but I see more of a direct line than she does between Virginia Smith and Donald Trump.
Virginia Smith, in my recollection, indulged in the same kind of fabulism that characterized the Trump era. In 1981, she did not push back in any way to the notion that a huge tax cut would balance the federal budget and have more left over to increase defense spending. Even David Stockman, the director of the Office of Management and Budget, confessed that no one really believed it. After Congress enacted the program, the country went into steep recession and Congress reversed much of it in 1982, after which the country slowly recovered, albeit with a greatly increased national debt.
But many of her Nebraska constituents believed it, just as they believe today that the 2020 election was stolen from Trump. The direct political heirs of Virginia Smith are Nebraska lawmakers Deb Fischer and Adrian Smith. I think they know that Trump did not win the election, but are not up to saying so, just as Virginia Smith was not up to telling her constituents the truth about magical economics forty years ago. Fabulism is alive and well in Nebraska, most strongly in the third district.
Virginia Smith's papers are at UNL. Now would be a good time to look at them to see what hints they provide as to whether she would or would not "even recognize" the party of Donald Trump. Many of today's Nebraska voters doubtless think she is of one piece with them.
Reasons to Disregard 11th-hour Memo on Student Loans
January, 2021
Washington – The Trump administration is making an eleventh-hour attempt to limit the ability of the incoming Biden administration to provide relief to federal student loan borrowers.
A new memorandum from an acting deputy general counsel at the Department of Education interprets very narrowly the Secretary of Education's statutory powers to compromise and settle loans. The memorandum, however, is off-base in describing the provision in question and makes major omissions regarding its historical interpretation and use.
In the 1990s, I worked at the Office of Legislation and Congressional Affairs at the department; the following decade I initiated litigation (largely successful) involving the provisions in question. So I am familiar with the territory covered by the memorandum.
I recall many internal department discussions in the 1990s about the use of 20 U.S.C. 1082, which gives the Secretary powers and duties to compromise and settle loan disputes. The statute was enacted many decades ago for the purpose of protecting the interests of the United States, which included the integrity of federal student loan programs. If other remedies to straighten out disputes failed, the Secretary could step in by law.
At that time, most disputes involved guaranty agencies, which handled the majority of federal student loans; the federal direct loan program was in its infancy and would not fully replace the bank-based loan system until 2010. Guaranty agencies' extensive powers and duties, for which they were funded by fees and federal payments, included authority over "cancelled loans...[and] borrower refunds, including those arising out of student or other borrower claims and defenses."
More than a few times at OLCA I had occasion to call guaranty agencies about loan disputes and request that they resolve them or else the Secretary would have to act. Those who administered the bank-based program in the early and mid-1990s, including secondary markets, were government agencies or non-profits, and usually resolved problems without further conflict.*
That changed toward the end of the decade, as government-sponsored enterprises and non-profits began to convert to for-profit status. In the early 2000s, previously unheard of profit levels tempted many student loan entities to cut corners on servicing and on federal subsidy claims. After successive audits by the department's inspector general showed fraudulent claims by lenders, Secretary of Education Margaret Spellings concurred with the audit conclusions in a January, 2007, decision, but notably gave blanket amnesty to all lenders that had made false claims. They would not have to repay so long as they agreed not to make more.
This action was approved by the Department of Justice and the Office of Management and Budget, based on the Secretary's power to compromise and settle. The generous treatment of lenders cost federal taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars, at a minimum. The Secretary said the total amount was unknowable and did not offer an estimate. She said she acted so as to prevent even greater losses.
All of which undermines the new memorandum's assertion that the Secretary is required to collect debts under the Federal Claims Collection Act**, which obligates agencies to “try to collect a claim of the United States Government for money . . . arising out of the activities of, or referred to, the agency." That was brushed aside in 2007. It also undermines arguments in the memorandum that settlements must be done on an individual, "case-by-case" basis, and that settling creates an unacceptable "moral hazard."
To omit decades of history of the application of the statute at issue is a fundamental flaw of the new memorandum.
As to what the limits of the powers are in 2021, I have suggested previously that compromise and settlement of borrowers' loans apply to all issues of program integrity, a long-standing interpretation going back decades. That includes the mishandling of "borrower defense" loan discharges, for which Secretary Betsy DeVos was once threatened with jail by a federal judge for failing to cancel loans as required by law; and the maladministration of the Public Service Loan Forgiveness program, which once was described in a headline, "Your Student Loan Servicer Will Call You Back in a Year. Sorry." It may also extend to borrowers who never had an opportunity to raise issues about their loans because of the DeVos-created doctrine of "preemption," under which consumer protection investigations by state attorneys general, among others, were never allowed to proceed by Secretary DeVos. That doctrine has now been set aside by many federal courts, but borrowers have had no relief from the deprivation of their consumer rights.
The compromise and cancellation powers clearly can be used to provide protection of the United States from huge financial losses. Through the use of the powers in cases where institutions have defrauded borrowers, and by requiring the schools to contribute to paying the costs, a strong signal would be sent to institutions to re-think business plans that rely on misleading and defrauding students (and sometimes parents) so as to profit from defenseless federal taxpayers left holding future defaults.
As to more general student loan cancellations, a case can be made that the very size of total borrower debt, and the troubling numbers of those unable ever to pay off their debts, indicate a breakdown of the federal loan program itself. There have been many recent proposals to reduce debt interest or principal, to adjust terms, to assign loans to reformed programs, and to target relief by demographic categories. Many of these ideas have merit and should be pursued through legislation. Some might be accommodated through the Secretary's compromise and settlement authority, if appropriately tied to historical interpretation and precedent. It is worth the effort, should legislative remedies not succeed.
However that turns out, it can already be said that the eleventh-hour memorandum from the Trump administration is not well-founded and should be disregarded by the incoming administration.
__________________________
* All were mindful of the late 1980s' collapse of the Higher Education Assistance Fund (HEAF), a Minnesota-based guaranty agency that federal taxpayers bailed out at a cost of hundreds of millions of dollars.
** On the occasion of the new memorandum's mention of the Federal Claims Collection Act, it seems appropriate to ask whether the Secretary has collected $22 million from a lender's false claims, which unpaid debt is over a decade old. See https://oha.ed.gov/oha/files/2019/03/2016-42-SA.pdf.
The Case for Methodical and Bi-Partisan Impeachment
January, 2021
Washington – What a week. The accounts of those trapped in the U.S. Capitol, calling for help, are the most unsettling to me. Moving furniture in front of doors, keeping quiet.
I worked in the Senate from 1979-84 and spent much time there, and in the House, from 1994-2001 as a federal agency congressional liaison. I've been back many times on various missions as a private citizen.
There must be consequences for those who committed crimes and for those who incited them.
The best way forward, unless someone has a better plan, is to impeach the President to hold him accountable, so he cannot run for office again, but to do it methodically over weeks or months. There seems to be no realistic way to do it in the few days remaining in his term.
The House should allow time for evidence to be gathered and other legal processes to move forward in the judicial system (both federal and state), so as to draft the articles properly. The House would then act to impeach, but hold the articles and not send them to the Senate until the votes are there to convict. Well-drafted and substantiated articles, passed with bi-partisan support from at least a few House Republicans, could result in a Senate conviction.
Impeachment articles should not be sent to the Senate if there is a substantial risk of acquittal. The act of a second impeachment is of huge consequence itself. It would also inform the historical record.
Impeachment should take a deliberate back seat to moving ahead with President Joe Biden's legislative agenda, which will seek bipartisan cooperation. Success with that agenda could pave the way for Senate conviction of Trump so as to preclude him from running again for any office.
This suggestion is similar to one I made in 2019, that the House should censure Donald Trump for his impeachable offenses, then initiate impeachment proceedings but not send impeachment articles to the Senate until there was a reasonable chance of conviction. Had the House held the first impeachment articles in abeyance, for however long, they would have been both a restraint on Trump's behavior and available in a crisis to be sent to the Senate for action.*
The key words now are methodical and bi-partisan. This will allow much new information to be gathered, including the possibility that impeachable offenses by others in office will be discovered. Once Donald Trump is no longer in power to wield fear of retribution, many who were a part of his administration may choose to cooperate with investigations, both congressional and judicial, to create a truthful record of the times.
Proceeding this way also allows the nation's focus to return to fighting the raging pandemic and shoring up cybersecurity measures, two other crises that need immediate and undivided attention.
If there is a need to remove the President before his term expires, the most likely route, it seems to me, would be for a handful of Senate Republicans to advise the Vice President that they will bolt the party if he does not act to invoke the 25th Amendment. Senate Democrats could aid this process by assuring the Senators that they would not lose their committee assignments and rankings for taking such action. Students of comparative government will recognize this as akin to actions in parliamentary systems, through which coalitions are formed to get through crises.
______________________
* Sending the impeachment articles to the Senate without the votes to convict was a major blunder by House Speaker Pelosi and the Democratic Leadership; we have now suffered the consequences.