Give These Borrowers Their Lives Back
Loan Cancellation Options for the Secretary of Education
June, 2021
Washington — In all the current back and forth about potential cancellation of federal student loans, for whom and in what amount, two crucial considerations are largely and regrettably absent from the discussion.
One is a management issue. Loan servicers often cannot properly handle loan administration even in the best of times. They will be overwhelmed later this year when the pandemic moratorium on loan repayment expires. It is in the best interest of the federal government to cancel loans where there is a good case to do so, simply to reduce loan administration volume.
The other consideration is the honor and credibility of the federal government. Many borrowers are in financial trouble and cannot repay their loans because of malfeasance and fraud at schools, or mistakes by the many middlemen involved in loan administration, including the U.S. Department of Education itself.
The Secretary of Education has statutory authority to compromise loan repayment obligations, which clearly extends to these two reasons for exercise of that authority. Rather than arguing about cancellation solely in terms of which borrowers may or may not benefit, the conversation needs urgently to turn to what's in cancellation simply for the cause of good and honest government.
First, the Secretary should take immediate steps to cancel the loans of borrowers who are legally entitled to cancellation. Who would that be? If you don't know, you haven't been paying attention. The Trump administration denied cancellation to many such borrowers.
Next, loans for which principal and the government's cost of interest have already been paid back should be cancelled to relieve borrowers of further payments. In many cases, remaining balances represent fees, penalties, and capitalizations that audits and accountability reviews trace to faulty servicer advice, which in turn is a function of an overly complicated loan system and poor administration of it.*
Next, with the input of the CFPB and SFA, a process of loan cancellation should be afforded to borrowers who have been caught in loan hell through no fault of their own. Where there is documented evidence that borrowers have been the victims of the mistakes of others' handling of their student loans, and no other remedy has been applied, the remaining balances should be cancelled. The very honor of the federal government is at stake here. Bankruptcy reforms should be a part of this discussion as another way for people to get their lives back.
The creative ideas of some in the higher education community to address the student loan crisis should be explored as a way to cancel even more loans. For example, applying "retroactive Pell" grant amounts to reduce the loan balances of former Pell-eligible borrowers could result in the cancellation of many small-balance loans, as well as a way to target loan relief to those most in need of it.**
Costs of loan compromises must be weighed against costs of business as usual, and discounted for the fact that huge percentages of current loans must be written off as uncollectible in any honest budget scoring.
I believe the Secretary's authority to compromise loans is broad and extends beyond the examples listed above but, simply for the sake of good government and honorable execution of the Department of Education's mission, the Secretary should act now to cancel as many loans as possible to avoid another looming crisis yet this year.
_____________________________
* Much of the rationale for the interest rates and fees now charged on federal student loans is a legacy of a dual loan delivery system, under which the Secretary was to provide equal terms and conditions between bank-based and direct government loans. That dual system no longer exists; any remaining bank-based paper could be bought up by the Secretary, who could also issue an emergency regulation to reset interest rates going forward at lower levels.
** I like the retroactive Pell concept because it eliminates schools' role in subjecting Pell to aid packaging formulas that often disadvantage low-income and minority students.
Lincoln's Unfortunate Housing Trends
There is an arms-race in Lincoln among homebuilders as to who can offer more garages and lay more concrete over frontages. No more is a two-car garage adequate; now houses have three, four, and even five garages in front. The houses themselves have to peek out from behind to show that, indeed, there is a house at the address, presumably with people living in it.
A view from the back side does not give much clue about residents, as the houses have tall, opaque fences around back yards.
I took some photos. Note the view of a new Lincoln development from above, showing the expanses of concrete that will contribute to downstream flooding. That is what the Climate Action Plan supposedly wants to avoid. Note the dark, heat absorbing roofs, driving up peak summer electrical usage, which the Climate Action Plan hopes to reduce.
![]() |
| Wide expanses of impervious surfaces |
Views from the front show small monoculture lawns, maintained by environmental toxins as hawked on television.
These are homesites where there are likely more garages per lot than earthworms.
Lincoln is not an environmentally friendly city, judging by its trends in housing construction. The same could be said for its esthetics; many urban sprawl developments have the look of self-storage businesses.
![]() |
| "Peek-a-boo" house style |
![]() |
| "Fortress Garage" model |
Compare another community that chose New Urbanism, this one in Maryland. Notice from the aerial view that there is much less concrete slab. Garages are tucked behind houses, entered via picturesque, tree-lined, carbon-storing alleys. Inhabitants walk to stores on sidewalks and pause to chat with neighbors on front porches. Many roofs have solar panels.
![]() |
| New Urbanism |
![]() |
| Porches in front of houses |
![]() | ||
Mixed income housing: townhouse, low income, single family options
|
Not all is bad in Lincoln housing development. Some areas, like the Telegraph district, are being turned into denser, walkable communities. Smart growth.
But when it comes to urban sprawl, please stop it, Lincoln. We're a better city than this.
Guest Blog on Insurrection (from 1861)
January-February, 1861
…I am rather glad South Carolina has taken this decisive step. Her arrogance and rashness have arrayed even her Southern neighbors against her. She will not be supported by a single State. I have not heard a voice raised in her behalf. Even those who have heretofore been most vociferous about Southern rights unite in condemning her premature presumption. A ship of war in the harbor of Charleston, and a battalion of nation troops thrown into the forts, will quench South Carolina as briefly as one may snuff out a tallow dip with his thumb and finger.
…”Sedition is like fire, easily extinguished at the commencement, but the longer it burns the more fiercely it blazes.”
… South Carolina is not quenched, and there seems to be no disposition on the part of those in power to out the extinguisher on her.
The effect of this state of things is distinctlible in the time of opinion around us. State Sovereignty dogmatism is becoming daily more open and arrogant. County court metaphysicians are modifying their Unionism with “ifs” and “ands” and “peradventures” – small anglers in the mud-puddle of village tavern opinion are drawing in their lines and changing their bait – petty politicians are craftily trimming their sails that their cock-boats may run with the rising wind. But while the weak-kneed are thus tottering, and trimmers fluttering in the breeze, the storm serves to fan to fiercer flame the indignation of all true men. All eyes and hearts are now turned toward Washington, expectant, eager, hopeful. There centres the power which in its infancy has met and twice foiled the giant of Great Britain, which in the very wontonness of its lusty youth made a holiday frolic of throttling poor Mexico. What will the Government do in this crisis?
…Is it secret sympathy with treason or mere driveling that tells the American people “the Government has no right to coerce a State?” – a nation that for more than eighty years has maintained fleets and armies, has waged wars and made peace, has collected customs and coined money; whose commerce covers the globe, whose flag is known and honored wherever the sun shines; whose power and civilization are acknowledged by the proudest and most enlightened peoples; whose future promises to surpass in grandeur all that history has yet recorded. Such a nation has not the right to suppress domestic insurrection! So vast an aggregation of power, prosperity, and hope must submit quietly and unresistingly to perish at the bidding of a local faction, a confederacy of visionary schemers, conceited dogmatists, self-deluding and self-stultifying economists – base huxters, who unblushingly pretend to barter the national honor and safety for the advantage of cheap negroes and a good cotton market; unprincipled politicians, whose vulpine instincts have warned them that the power and places which they had so long abused and so deeply corrupted are about to be withdrawn from their keeping!
Is nothing lawful or constitutional but the outrages of revolutionary mobs, the violation of solemn oaths, the plundering of national property, and the babbling of seditious orators?
Is the Government we have loved and trusted indeed so pitiable and impotent a sham? Have the founders, whom we have been accustomed to regard as wise and good men, really put such a scurvy trick upon us? Have we built houses, laid up wealth, begot children, acquired honors, and recreated in boasting and self-glorification under the delusion of a Political Idea that would disgrace a council of Pottawatomies?
Such are the questions that loyal Virginians in the bitterness of their humiliation now all each other, as the daily mails bring in the accumulating details of rebel outrage, arrogance, and menace, responded to only by governmental acquiescence, deprecatory remonstrance, and despicable compromise.
Head-Scratching over Rural Nebraska
May, 2021
Lincoln — Rural Nebraska interests gained special attention this month in the Nebraska legislature, but in head-scratching ways.
Rural regions have been losing population disproportionately. In response, the Nebraska Farm Bureau made a presentation to the legislature's redistricting committee, asking that it make rural representation in legislative bodies a priority over other considerations, so as to stem the decline of rural voices.
But it's the height of irony for the Farm Bureau to make that argument without acknowledging that the depopulation has been in large part due to the "get-big-or-get-out" farm policy long embraced by the Farm Bureau itself. This was the doctrine first enunciated so pithily by the Nixon Administration's Earl Butz and repeated more recently by the Trump Administration's Sonny Perdue. A lot of farmers got out, and now the Farm Bureau is pleading for the legislature to make up for it. This is akin to the old saw about the child who murdered his parents but pleaded with the judge for mercy because he was an orphan.
But reaction to another legislative development prompts downright forehead slapping. A Lincoln Journal Star editorial commended the legislature for advancing, 43-0, a measure to develop local farm-to-school markets. It offered, however, this analysis:
"[W]e question why local schools haven't always purchased from in-state farmers and why such an apparent no-brainer requires state legislation. We are in the midst of America's breadbasket, aren't we? Farming and ranching represent a large chunk of Nebraska's economy and keep the state economy churning...."[W]e'd still be remiss for questioning the need for appropriating about $100,000 annually, to hire a statewide coordinator for the program. It seems that Nebraska's farmers would need no prodding in applying to be included in this networking opportunity.... In a $9 billion budget, $100,000 is a drop in the bucket. ... This is a worthy project, but it’s a shame it will take additional spending to make it happen."
The Arc of the Moral Universe
May, 2021
Lincoln and Washington — Nearly a year ago in these pages I suggested replacing, in the U.S. Senate Reception Room, the portrait of Senator John C. Calhoun, of South Carolina, with a portrait of Senator George W. Norris, of Nebraska. (I know the room well, having worked as Senate staff for several years and as a federal agency liaison to Congress for several more.)
Calhoun (1782-1850) advocated for slavery in the 19th century and was noted for his political theories of nullification and secession. Norris (1861-1944) was a champion for rural America in the 20th. Norris was chosen by a Senate committee in the 1950s for representation in the ornate room, one of only five selected from among all senators who had ever served, but intra-party wounds in his home state were still fresh; Nebraska senators Carl Curtis and Roman Hruska blocked the choice.
A saying attributed to several individuals, in various forms over two centuries, is that the arc of the moral universe is long but it bends toward justice. Left unanswered is who does the bending, which is where my personal interest in these portraits enters the equation.
When the ancestors of Senator John C. Calhoun moved from Pennsylvania to South Carolina in the early days of our country, they stopped for a generation in Virginia. Among those who remained longer, in Pendleton County, Virginia, was William Calhoun, who married my 3rd great-grandmother. They named their son, born in 1840, John C. Calhoun, after his father's famous South Carolina cousin. The Virginia namesake of the senator was my 2nd great-granduncle, half-brother of my 2nd great-grandfather, Sampson Zickafoose. He and Sampson enlisted in the Confederate army in 1861.
They both died in the summer of 1863: namesake John C. at the Battle of Williamsport, covering Lee's retreat from Gettysburg, and Sampson, most likely of disease.
When Sampson's son Clark Zicafoose married Susan Wimer in 1880, he married into the Strother family, which had abolitionists in its ranks. Susan's ancestors included Anthony and Frances Eastham Strother, who gave up their slaves when they became abolitionist Baptists many years before the Civil War. They are my 5th great-grandparents. (Not all in the Strother family were abolitionists, however; President Zachary Taylor, my 1st cousin five times removed, was a slave-owner.)
Clark Zicafoose and Susan Wimer Zicafoose migrated to Nebraska in the 1890s, first to Lancaster County and then to Red Willow County, where they lived outside McCook, home of George Norris. Clark died in 1927 but Susan lived until 1941, long enough to see rural America benefit from Norris's creation of the Rural Electrification Administration (REA). Clark and Susan Zicafoose were probably supporters of George Norris, of their hometown. My father, born in 1912 in McCook to their daughter, Mae Zicafoose Oberg, was a great admirer of Norris.
Which brings us to the insurrection at the U.S. Capitol on January 6, 2021. One hopes that the insurrectionists were not inspired to invade the Senate chamber by the Calhoun portrait in the Reception Room. Nothing in the investigations so far suggests it, but it could have been a provocation. (The invaders did, however, damage a bust of Zachary Taylor in a Senate hallway during their rampage, probably without knowing who he was.)
I don't believe the moral arc bends itself. It is bent toward justice, or not, by choices, including the choice of which people to honor even within one's own family. Sampson Zicafoose and his half-brother John C. Calhoun, Confederate soldiers, have headstones in recognized cemeteries in Pendleton County, now West Virginia. Sarah Strother* Wimer, of the abolitionist Strothers and my 2nd great-grandmother, has none. Her gravesite is in a family plot somewhere nearby, the exact location of which is in doubt.
I would like to find it, perhaps put a headstone there, and bend the arc toward justice a little within my own family. A good occasion for the attempt would be a U.S. Senate decision to put the portrait of John C. Calhoun in a museum and install instead a portrait of George W. Norris. It's long overdue.
_________________________________________
* The spelling changed to Strawder at some point, likely a phonetic rendering. We don't know the sentiments of Sarah Strother Wimer (1830-1875), herself, about slavery or the Confederacy. Her husband Peter B. Wimer was a Confederate soldier from 1861-1863, like their neighbors near Dry Run, Sampson Zicafoose and John C. Calhoun. Her cousin, however, the estimable David Hunter Strother, well-known as "Porte Crayon," was a Union army brevet general.
From the Palatinate to Virginia to Nebraska
April, 2021
Lincoln – Genealogical research, inspired by provocations in literature, can turn up surprising finds, especially now with primary sources so widely available. Such is the case after my own reading of Willa Cather's last, thinly-disguised novel based on her family, published in 1940 and set in Virginia, 1856. Some of my family has the same European and Virginia heritage, and made the same choice to migrate to Nebraska. We surely can benefit from a comparison of similar and interwoven experiences.
In 1738, two brothers from the Rhineland Palatinate crossed the Atlantic to start a new life in America. After a few years in Pennsylvania, Johan Wendel Seybert, with his wife Catherine Reiss, settled near the Potomac in the mountainous part of Frederick County, Virginia, beyond Winchester, where their descendants would farm along the Back Creek tributary for generations and where Willa Cather would be born.
His brother Johan Jacob Seybert, with his mother, Anna Lorentz, his wife, Maria Elizabeth Theiss, and their children settled further upstream near the South Potomac headwaters, in Virginia's Augusta County highlands. George Washington, of the British colonial army, ordered the construction of Fort Seybert to protect the settlers during the French and Indian War, but to no avail. Johan Jacob Seybert, his mother, his wife, and several of their children were killed by Shawnee in the Fort Seybert massacre of April 28, 1758. Other children, including one year old George, were taken captive to be raised as Shawnee. George was eventually rescued by his teenage brother Nickolas; in all, five Seybert children made their way back to Augusta County.
In 1771, three brothers from a different family, in my ancestral line, also left the Palatinate for America, along with their parents Henry and Catherine Harper Weimer (Wimer). The parents died at sea. The teenage brothers Jacob, Philip, and George were sold into indentured servitude on arrival in Philadelphia to pay the ship's captain for transport. Philip was sent to Augusta County, Virginia, where after seven years his brothers joined him. Philip and George each married and raised families there.
The two ill-fated families, the Seyberts and the Wimers, were linked in 1813 when George Seybert's daughter Sarah married George Wimer's son Jacob.
Both the immigrant Philip Wimer and his son, Philip Wimer, Jr., became slave-owners, as did the Seybert (Seibert, Sibert) family of Back Creek. Willa Sibert Cather picked up the story in Sapphira and the Slave Girl, which she explained was more fact than fiction. Her great grandmother Rhuamah Lemmon, of a prominent Winchester family (and "Sapphira" in the novel), brought several slaves into the family when she married Jacob Funk Seibert, grandson of the immigrant Johan Wendel Seybert.
The Civil War and the Thirteenth Amendment ended slavery. During the conflict, a part of former Augusta County, which had been redrawn as Pendleton County, became part of the new state of West Virginia. Philip Wimer, Jr.'s son, Peter B. Wimer, who fought for the Confederacy, left Pendleton County for Nebraska after the war, settling in Lancaster County. Rhuamah Lemmon Seibert's daughter Rachel Seibert Boak, her daughter Mary Elizabeth (nicknamed "Jennie") Cather, and Jennie's daughter Willa, age nine, along with others of the Cather family into which Jennie married, left their Virginia homes in Frederick County for Webster County, Nebraska. Some of the Seiberts had fought for the Confederacy; the Cathers were Unionists.
Descendants of the massacred Seyberts made their way to Nebraska as well, including Isaac Seybert and his son Andrew Seybert, who settled in Cass and Otoe counties. Andrew married a descendant of Peter Thomas Hull, a Virginia ancestor of several Wimers and a captain in the Revolutionary Army in whose Augusta Militia company Nicholas Seybert, the one-time Shawnee captive, had served.
The migration to Nebraska included extended families and neighbors. The Cather family was joined on The Divide in Webster county by the Lockhart, Larrick, and Lewis families, their Back Creek neighbors. The Cather children attended the "New Virginia" country school. The Wimers in northern Lancaster County were part of an extended family that included former Virginians of the Phares, Bland, Lambert, Mullenax, Calhoun, Zicafoose, Higgins, and Strawder (Strother) families.
Philip Wimer, Sr., was my fourth great-grandfather. Peter Thomas Hull, who settled in Augusta County in 1752 and for whom Fort Seybert was protection, was my sixth great-grandfather. Among my DNA cousins are several Seyberts and Seiberts. A Strother cousin was the next-door neighbor of the Seiberts on Back Creek in the years following the Civil War, when former slaves Matilda Jefferson ("Till" in the novel) and Thomas Parrot ("Sampson") were listed as servant and miller, respectively, in the U.S. Census of 1870. My grandmother Ressie Mae Zicafoose Oberg, daughter of Susan Wimer and William Clark Zicafoose, was born in Dry Run, Pendleton County, West Virginia, in 1884 and moved to Nebraska at age nine onto the farm of her grandfather, Peter B. Wimer.
All of which raises many questions. Did the families of the brothers Johan Wendel and Johan Jacob Seybert keep in touch after the Shawnee massacre and did Willa Cather even know of the fate of part of her family at Fort Seybert? There seems to be little in the Cather scholarship about it.
With family histories of Indian captivity and indentured servitude, and thus presumably an enhanced appreciation of human freedom, why did the Seyberts and Wimers become slave-owners themselves?
As a Nebraskan with roots in the Palatinate, in colonial America, and in slave-holding Virginia, I especially appreciate Cather's attempt to deal with her family's history and believe Sapphira to be among her bests works, because it hits so close to home. She even dares to put herself into the book in the epilogue, a first-person account of herself at age five, witnessing at Back Creek the happy post-Civil-War visit of a former slave girl, now living in Canada, whom her grandmother Rachel Seibert Boak had helped escape from the Seibert family in 1856.
What schools, parks, or other public places are named for Rachel, an undaunted Virginia abolitionist within the Seibert family and an early Nebraska pioneer? None that I know of. There should be some. We should all have such ancestors in our family trees; maybe we do if we look for them. I am looking in mine.
Better Days Ahead
April, 2021
Washington – A year ago I wrote, in this post, that "better days may be coming" in about a year. Despite some of darkest days in our country's history, those better days may soon be upon us. Nothing could be more symbolic than this picture, which the Washington Post published. It was taken Sunday, April 11, 2021.
Biden's Better Start at USDA
April, 2021
Washington and Lincoln – The Biden administration is off to a good start for rural America and USDA. On day one, the President signed an executive order on equity, which specifically included in its definition "persons who live in rural areas." "Geographic communities" are finally getting their due.
He followed up by naming Kelliann Blazek as special assistant to the president for agriculture and rural policy. She brings formidable qualifications to the job, having worked for the National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition, as counsel to Congresswoman (and farmer) Chellie Pingree of the House Agriculture Committee, and as faculty at George Mason law school.Avoiding a Student Loan Servicing Meltdown
April, 2021
Washington – A new warning from five nonprofit higher education organizations about an impending student loan servicing meltdown is as ominous as it is true:
To mitigate the challenges facing borrowers during the pandemic, the Biden Administration extended the pause on payments, interest, and collections for most federal student loan borrowers through September 30, 2021. When the pause ends, tens of millions of borrowers will move back into repayment simultaneously. The difficulties borrowers face are likely to persist even as the economy re-opens and the COVID crisis subsides. The impending transition out of the repayment pause is an unprecedented challenge for the Education Department (ED), the Office of Federal Student Aid (FSA), and its contracted loan servicers. In fact, recent survey work indicates that as many as nine million borrowers could reach out for help at the same time, potentially overwhelming the system. [emphasis added]
There is no good reason for confidence that the Education Department's current servicers will be up to the task. Some of them have failed miserably at simpler tasks; two of the three primary servicers have been sued for their failures by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and by several state attorneys general under state consumer protection laws.
What would help in this situation is to reduce the number of loans the servicers must handle. Much ink has been spilled about whether loans should be forgiven up to $10,000, or $50,000, or entirely, based on various rationales, some compelling and some less so, and if the Secretary can do this by executive authority or if it takes an act of Congress. Such loan forgiveness in any amount would reduce the number of loans outstanding significantly. The Biden Administration has asked the Department of Justice for an opinion on the question, but many people familiar with DOJ's borrower-unfriendly history expect the opinion to say any such loan forgiveness requires legislative, not executive, action.
There is another alternative, short of outright forgiveness, that would reduce the number of loans. The Secretary could start now to offer borrowers the option of repaying immediately a discounted value of their loans, to get the loans off the books for the benefit of both the borrowers and the U.S. government. Many loans have already been discounted heavily in the federal budgeting process because they are in default, or the borrowers are already eligible for discharges, or borrowers will be eligible for future forgiveness under various programs such as the Public Service Loan Forgiveness program.
The federal treasury is never going to see much revenue from these loans, so it would make sense to get rid of the burden of administering them.
If I were a borrower in the PSLF program, which has poor prospects* of ever being straightened out, I might gladly repay an appropriately discounted loan amount and be done with it, rather than holding out hope for competently-administered cancellation of my loan in exchange for my public service.
Another option would be for the Secretary to offer borrowers who have been faithfully in repayment for a certain number of years the opportunity to pay off their loans at principal plus interest at the government's cost of borrowing. As I am reminded by those who know, federal student loan interest rate formulas (and fees and capitalizations) were established decades ago in an environment requiring equity between different federal loan programs, not on the basis of otherwise prevailing interest rates. That time has long since passed.
These options to reduce the number of loans are consistent with a plain reading of the Secretary's authority to settle and compromise loans under 20 U.S.C. 1082. This is what a private business would likely do in similar circumstances. And DOJ had no objections when, several years ago, a Secretary of Education wrote off hundreds of millions of dollars of lenders' liability to repay false claims, because the Secretary said it was in the government's interest to do so. If that was the case then**, it is much more the case now, when the entire credibility of federal student loan administration hangs in the balance.
These options would also meet with fewer objections from those who allege that any outright loan cancellation is unfair and inequitable. The relief would come largely to borrowers for whom the federal student loan system has failed, as many were short-changed by schools that should never have been in business and prepared students inadequately to pay back their loans; by servicers that could not keep their paperwork straight or gave borrowers bad advice as to their best repayment options; and by four most recent years of a borrower-hostile federal Education Department that too often actually denied borrowers their rights under law.***
The benefits of substantially reducing the number of student loans will accrue to the government, to borrowers who need a fresh start without student loan debt, and to taxpayers generally who will benefit by a significant boost to the economy as student debt burdens are lifted.
_________________________
* The Massachusetts attorney general recently reached settlement with the PSLF servicer PHEAA to compensate that state's borrowers for deficiencies in loan administration. If this proceeds on a state-by-state basis, rather than being resolved at the federal level, it is likely many borrowers will never see the benefits they are entitled to under law.
** In May, 2007, Secretary Margaret Spellings told the House Committee on Education and Labor, and later reiterated, that the Education Department itself had partial culpability for lenders' overcharges, and that the best course was to forgive the corporations' obligation to repay rather than to litigate the matter.
*** Of late there have been allegations of racial discrimination in the distribution of student debt burden. This is not a surprise; in 2003 in a working paper for the Institute of Education Sciences, I found that public and nonprofit colleges' financial aid packaging practices placed higher debt burdens on the black low-income. This was even without inclusion of for-profit colleges in the dataset and is another reason the Secretary should craft debt relief to include this demographic.







